Many-to-Many Relationships in Power BI: How to Avoid Them

Many-to-many relationships in Power BI often lead to ambiguous or inaccurate results when not modeled correctly. Although Power BI supports such relationships, they can introduce complexity, performance challenges, and filter confusion. This blog explains what many-to-many relationships are, why they may pose problems, and the best practices to avoid them when building clean and efficient data models.

Why Many-to-Many Relationships Occur in Power BI?

Many-to-many relationships in Power BI arise when both tables in a relationship contain non-unique values in the joining column. In such cases, Power BI cannot establish a clear “one” side, leading to ambiguous connections.

For example, if Table A and Table B both have multiple rows with the same OrderID, and neither column contains only unique values, Power BI recognizes this as a many-to-many scenario. These types of relationships are supported but often introduce complexity in filtering and reporting.

Issues with Many-to-Many Relationships in Power BI

While many-to-many relationships in Power BI offer flexibility, they come with several drawbacks:

• Ambiguous Filter Propagation
  Filters may behave unpredictably, leading to incorrect totals or unexpected results in visuals.
• Performance Overhead
  Complex joins and calculations may slow down reports, especially with large datasets.
• Unreliable Aggregations
  Measures and totals can return incorrect values due to overlapping data paths.

Avoiding these issues often results in a more stable and performant data model.

Common Scenario: Duplicate Keys in Both Tables

Many-to-many relationships in Power BI typically occur when both tables involved contain duplicate values in the join column, and neither has a unique key. This makes it impossible for Power BI to enforce a one-to-many structure.

Example: Consider Orders and OrderDetails table. The structure of these tables is provided below:

The OrderDetails table contains duplicate OrderID values, which is expected — a single order can include multiple items. However, the Orders table also contains duplicate OrderID values, which is incorrect. Ideally, the Orders table should have unique OrderIDs, while the OrderDetails table can have multiple rows per order. Although this is a data quality issue, such scenarios can commonly occur in enterprise environments.

Result in Power BI

When Power BI tries to build a relationship on OrderID:

• It detects duplicates on both sides.
• It cannot enforce a one-to-many relationship.
• A many-to-many relationship is automatically created, which may:
  • Inflate totals
  • Cause duplicate records in visuals
  • Lead to unexpected filter behavior

How to Resolve Many-to-Many Relationships in Power BI

To avoid issues caused by many-to-many relationships in Power BI, it’s essential to model the data with clear relationship paths and unique identifiers. Below are several best practices for resolving or preventing such situations:

1. Ensure Uniqueness in Lookup Tables

The table on the “one” side of the relationship should always have unique values in the key column (e.g., OrderID in the Orders table). Use Power Query Editor to remove duplicate rows or validate the uniqueness before establishing relationships.

2. Use Bridge Tables When Necessary

If a true many-to-many scenario exists (e.g., a product can appear in multiple orders and vice versa), create a bridge table that contains unique combinations of the shared key. This allows two one-to-many relationships to be established instead of one many-to-many.

3. Normalize the Data Model

Design the model using a star schema approach:

• Fact tables (e.g., OrderDetails) should relate to dimension tables (e.g., Orders, Products, Customers) through unique keys.
• Avoid connecting fact tables directly to each other when possible.

4. Review Relationships in Model View

Use Power BI’s Model View to confirm that:

• The relationship direction is clear (preferably single-direction).
• Cardinality is set as One-to-Many (1:*), not Many-to-Many (:).
• Lookup tables appear on the correct side of each relationship.

Best Practice to Resolve Many-to-Many Relationships

In a well-structured model:

• The Orders table should contain unique OrderID values.
• The OrderDetails table may contain repeated OrderID values (as each order can have multiple items).
• The relationship between Orders and OrderDetails should be One-to-Many (1:*) — avoiding many-to-many issues entirely.

Such a structure ensures clean filtering and accurate aggregations throughout the report.

In a well-structured model:

• The Orders table should contain unique OrderID values.
• The OrderDetails table may contain repeated OrderID values (as each order can have multiple items).
• The relationship between Orders and OrderDetails should be One-to-Many (1:*) — avoiding many-to-many issues entirely.

Such a structure ensures clean filtering and accurate aggregations throughout the report.

Summary

Although many-to-many relationships in Power BI are supported, they are rarely the optimal choice. Avoiding them leads to better performance, clearer data flows, and more accurate reports. By structuring the model with clean keys, using bridge tables when needed, and maintaining lookup tables, Power BI reports become faster, more maintainable, and easier to troubleshoot.

Expand Your Power BI Skills

Interested in mastering Power BI beyond the basics?

Explore the comprehensive guide Mastering Power BI, Second Edition — packed with advanced data modeling, DAX techniques, and real-world reporting strategies.

If you’re looking for hands-on, instructor-led Power BI training, contact us today to learn more about upcoming courses and private training options.

---